• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Formaggios Pie Shack

Formaggios Pie Shack, nestled on Highbury Ave in London, ON, is a culinary gem renowned for its hearty and flavorful fare. Guests rave about the extensive menu, featuring everything from decadent deep-dish pizzas to loaded nachos and custom pasta specials. The cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for gatherings, whether casual or celebratory, as exemplified by a recent birthday dinner that delighted a party of 23. With attentive service and reasonable prices, this restaurant not only fills your stomach but also warms your heart. For a delightful dining experience, Formaggios Pie Shack is a must-visit destination.

Formaggios Pie Shack: Reviews & Ratings

Tarsius Maximus
Tarsius Maximus

Normally we order the deep dish for takeout but we wanted to try a sit in experience. Absolutely one of the best resturants in London. Food was excellent! We had the combo platter, and bbq chicken flatbread. The chili bowl, pizza, and cocktails were amazing. My gf loved her penne pasta dish. Price and service is spectacular.

Johnny Prop
Johnny Prop

Local sweet spot. Everything ive ordered from here was filling and deliscious. I love their loaded nachos especially. Philly Cheesesteak, custom pasta special and the wings all excellent choices. Cozy atmosphere and staff is awesome. Perfect spot to watch the game and have a few well priced pints cheers

Jen Givens
Jen Givens

We recently hosted a birthday dinner for my brother at Formaggios with a group of 23 people, and everything was fantastic! The food and drinks were delicious, the service was above average — friendly, attentive, and well-organized — and the prices were very reasonable, especially for a large group. Everyone left happy and full! We’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend for any special occasion or night out!

Matthew Le Sage
Matthew Le Sage

Worth the drive!!! I had the stuffed deep dish pizza that was cooked to perfection, cheese browned on top and the crust great tasting while holding together the HUGE amount of cheese and toppings. The service was excellent and friendly. I live over an hour away and will be making trek again.

Stella
Stella

The amount of food is massive. I’m surprised how cheap the price is compared to other place too.My boyfriend’s family and I enjoyed our breakfast in this place. I understand that the food is a little late when they served it, but we also have had 5 plates for us. Our server is very accommodating and gave our request promptly. I would try their pancakes next time!

Courtney Oud
Courtney Oud

We drove about an hour and a half to try this place after someone at work sent photos of her take out order. Totally worth it. The deep dish pizza was really unique (I hadn’t had pizza sized in pounds before, instead of inches) and super tasty. The dining room is small and dark, but the server was really nice and the pitchers of good beer were only 15. Definitely try it, but make sure to be ready to take leftovers home.

Wilf Riecker
Wilf Riecker

Went for the Londonlicious feature. 3 courses for 35 and no tax. Had the hot dip appetizer, personal deep dish pizza and brownie alamode for dessert. The brownie was super sweet. Could only finish half the pizza. Will have the rest for lunch. All good and great value. Quality and reasonably priced wines extensive draft beer selection. Warm and friendly service. An Italian gem. Will definitely be back.

Dan Lu
Dan Lu

Incredible breakfast! Great atmosphere, the staff is extremely friendly, the taste is on point plus incredible value for the quality! Our new favorite breakfast place!

Location

Welcome to Formaggios Pie Shack, a delightful culinary gem located at 1600 Highbury Ave N, London, ON N5Y 5N7, Canada. With its cozy ambiance and charming decor, this eatery has quickly become a fan favorite for food lovers seeking hearty and delicious fare. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for any occasion—whether you're enjoying a casual dinner with friends or celebrating a special event.

What truly sets Formaggios apart is its diverse menu that caters to a variety of palates. Customers rave about the deep dish pizza, often described as a must-try for its rich flavors and generous toppings. The combo platter offers a delightful selection that showcases the restaurant's versatility, making it an excellent choice for sharing or indulging solo. For something different, the bbq chicken flatbread and loaded nachos have also garnered praise, proving to be crowd-pleasers that hit the mark every time.

The wings and custom pasta specials have received accolades for their taste and creativity, while the Philly Cheesesteak keeps diners coming back for more. For those seeking to unwind, the drink selection features well-priced cocktails and pints—ideal for watching the game with friends.

What many patrons appreciate most is the attentive and friendly service. Reviews highlight the efficient staff who go out of their way to ensure a pleasant dining experience. Whether it's accommodating a large group or addressing special requests, Formaggios excels in hospitality, making their guests feel well cared for.

With a commitment to quality and flavor at reasonable prices, Formaggios Pie Shack stands as a beacon for food enthusiasts in London. If you’re looking for a spot that combines delightful dishes with a warm atmosphere, this is the place to be. Visit or call them at +1 519-457-2233 to grab a slice of the action—your taste buds will thank you!